This site may earn chapter commissions from the links on this page. Terms of use.

Apple's newest Macbooks feature a nifty Touch Bar and increased hard drive options

In June, afterward months of increasing customer complaints and song unhappiness, Apple tree kicked off a programme to supervene upon the keyboards of customers who had stuck or non-responsive keys. At that place was a precipitous increase in the number and frequency of these complaints later Apple switched to a new keyboard design in 2022, especially as the new design rolled out across Apple's entire product lines. At present, a new iFixit teardown into the keyboards explores what went wrong.

Among them — and as one example — apparently the Apple-designed butterfly-switch spacebar is and then delicate, it breaks every single fourth dimension information technology'south removed from the keyboard, even by a professional. The blueprint of the keyboard makes it impossible to switch key caps, and the design of the laptops makes it impossible to merely switch keyboards. To quote iFixit:

The keyboard itself can't but be swapped out. You can't fifty-fifty bandy out the upper case containing the keyboard on its own. You also have to supersede the glued-in battery, trackpad, and speakers at the same fourth dimension. For Apple tree'southward service team, the entire upper half of the laptop is a single component. That's why Apple has been charging through the nose and taking forever on these repairs. And that's why information technology's such a big deal—for customers and for shareholders—that Apple tree is extending the warranty. It's a damned expensive way to dust a laptop…

We put a keycap nether a microscope and injected a grain of sand so you lot tin can run into how this happens. The grain is in the bottom right corner, and information technology's completely blocking the key press activity. It's very challenging to remove information technology with compressed air.

butterfly-switch

According to iFixit, the particle of sand wedges itself underneath the butterfly cap, preventing it from depressing. Because there's virtually no way to remove the space bar (and none without breaking it), it's almost incommunicable to prepare. And considering it'south virtually impossible to set up, nosotros have a remarkable state of affairs in which the richest company on Earth has built a laptop in which 1 of the most mutual substances on Globe, which is itself a synonym for dirt, tin interruption a laptop and require the replacement of a very expensive set of components.

Thinness Is Neither a Moral Good Nor a Product Necessity

What's striking about this problem is that it isn't the first or fifty-fifty 2nd fourth dimension Apple has been caught out in recent years regarding the thinness of its product designs. By my count, information technology'southward at least the third. Start, the visitor decided to remove strengthening and stabilizing reinforcement from the iPhone half-dozen, leading to 'touch illness' — and court documents released earlier this year confirm that Apple knew, beyond any shadow of a incertitude, that the iPhone 6 was 3.3x more than probable to bend than the iPhone 5s, while the iPhone 6 Plus was 7.2x more likely to bend than the iPhone 5s. Information technology knew before it released the devices. It knew, and released them anyhow, considering thinness is the only thing that matters.

Then, there's last year's battery problems. Apple uses smaller batteries than its competitors, and it aggressively pushes the envelope on CPU clock and efficiency. So when Apple batteries began buckling nether discharge strain, the company decided to artificially choke CPU operation rather than ain up to the problem. And now, in the pursuit of twoscore percent thinner keys, Apple designed a laptop so stupidly thin, not only can the keyboard non be repaired by Apple, but information technology has to supervene upon huge sections of the entire laptop to fix a keyboard.

Apple tree, at this point, is sacrificing features that users do care virtually, like basic longevity, in pursuit of thinness. But "thinness," while useful and undeniably a motivating tendency from users overall, is not a moral skilful. It is non something that is simply more valuable than other traits in a vacuum. It doesn't trump the value of a keyboard that doesn't break, a phone that doesn't bend, or a battery that doesn't crave killing a telephone's functioning to maintain.

Part of beingness a trendsetter is knowing when a trend has run its form. If Apple tree hasn't figured out by now that simply making products thinner is not making its products better, it needs to do so.